Israel Rivera I

Executive Board Trial Results 10-25-2010

# Keypad Name Response

1 Motion to vote Israel Rivera Jr guilty on charge #1 

1 Terry Adams Abstain 

2 Tony Aiken Yes 

3 Brussard Alston Yes 

4 Lloyd Archer Abstain 

5 Frank Austin Yes 

6 Edwin Benjamin Yes 

7 Jack Blazejewicz Yes 

8 Dennis Boyd No 

9 Ron Carter No

10 John V Chiarello Yes 

11 Eze Chisolm Yes 

12 Brian Clarke Yes 

13 Tommy Creegan No 

14 Latonya Crisp‐Saura Yes 

15 Richard Davis Yes 

18 Grigory Dunichev Yes 

19 Jolly Eapen No 

20 Derrick Echevarria Yes 

22 Pete Foley Yes

23 Mario Galvet Yes 

24 Angel Giboyeaux Yes 

25 Jerry Greenhaus Yes 

26 Annie Hallahan Yes 

27 Kevin Harrington Yes 

28 Lee Ireland Yes 

29 Maurice Jenkins Yes 

30 Benita Johnson Yes 

31 Tom Lenane Yes 

33 Cleveland Manley Yes 

34 Shirley Martin Yes 

35 Dennis McCormick Yes 

38 Gwendolina Peebles Abstain

39 Neil Phillips No 

40 Paul Piazza Yes 

41 Nelson Rivera Yes 

44 John H. Spicer, Jr Yes 

45 Robert H. Stahl Yes 

46 K.Taylor‐Davidson Yes 

48 Tony Utano Yes 

49 Brander White Yes 

50 Christine Williams Yes 

52 Michael Morales Yes 

53 Joe Sclafani Yes

# Keypad Name Response

2 Motion to vote Israel Rivera, Jr. Guilty of the allegations in Charge #2 

1 Terry Adams Yes 

2 Tony Aiken Yes 

3 Brussard Alston Abstain

4 Lloyd Archer Yes 

5 Frank Austin Yes 

6 Edwin Benjamin Yes 

7 Jack Blazejewicz Yes 

8 Dennis Boyd Yes 

9 Ron Carter Yes

10 John V Chiarello Yes 

11 Eze Chisolm Yes 

12 Brian Clarke Yes 

13 Tommy Creegan No 

14 Latonya Crisp‐Saura Yes 

15 Richard Davis Yes 

18 Grigory Dunichev Yes 

19 Jolly Eapen Yes 

20 Derrick Echevarria Yes 

22 Pete Foley Yes 

23 Mario Galvet Yes 

24 Angel Giboyeaux Yes 

25 Jerry Greenhaus Yes 

26 Annie Hallahan Yes 

27 Kevin Harrington Yes

  28 Lee Ireland Yes 

29 Maurice Jenkins Yes 

30 Benita Johnson Yes 

31 Tom Lenane Yes 

33 Cleveland Manley Yes 

34 Shirley Martin Abstain 

35 Dennis McCormick Yes

38 Gwendolina Peebles Yes 

40 Paul Piazza Yes

41 Nelson Rivera Yes 

44 John H. Spicer, Jr Yes 

45 Robert H. Stahl Yes 

46 K.Taylor‐Davidson Yes 

48 Tony Utano Yes 

49 Brander White Yes 

50 Christine Williams Yes 

52 Michael Morales Yes 

53 Joe Sclafani Yes

# Keypad Name Response

3 Motion to vote Israel Rivera, Jr. Guilty of the allegations in Charge #3 

1 Terry Adams Abstain 

2 Tony Aiken Yes 

3 Brussard Alston Yes

4 Lloyd Archer Yes 

5 Frank Austin Yes 

6 Edwin Benjamin Yes 

7 Jack Blazejewicz Yes 

8 Dennis Boyd Yes 

9 Ron Carter Yes

10 John V Chiarello Yes 

11 Eze Chisolm Yes 

12 Brian Clarke Yes 

13 Tommy Creegan No 

14 Latonya Crisp‐Saura Yes 

15 Richard Davis Yes 

18 Grigory Dunichev Yes 

19 Jolly Eapen Yes 

20 Derrick Echevarria Yes 

22 Pete Foley Yes 

23 Mario Galvet Yes 

24 Angel Giboyeaux Yes 

25 Jerry Greenhaus Yes 

26 Annie Hallahan Yes 

27 Kevin Harrington Yes

  28 Lee Ireland Yes 

29 Maurice Jenkins Yes 

30 Benita Johnson Yes 

31 Tom Lenane Yes 

33 Cleveland Manley Yes 

34 Shirley Martin Yes 

35 Dennis McCormick Yes

38 Gwendolina Peebles Yes 

40 Paul Piazza Yes

41 Nelson Rivera Yes 

44 John H. Spicer, Jr Yes 

45 Robert H. Stahl Yes 

46 K.Taylor‐Davidson Yes 

48 Tony Utano Yes 

49 Brander White Yes 

50 Christine Williams Yes 

52 Michael Morales Yes 

53 Joe Sclafani Yes

# Keypad Name Response

4 Motion to vote Israel Rivera, Jr. Guilty of the allegations in Charge #4 

1 Terry Adams Yes 

2 Tony Aiken Yes 

3 Brussard Alston Yes

4 Lloyd Archer Yes 

5 Frank Austin Yes 

6 Edwin Benjamin Yes 

7 Jack Blazejewicz Yes 

8 Dennis Boyd Yes 

9 Ron Carter Yes

10 John V Chiarello Yes 

11 Eze Chisolm Yes 

12 Brian Clarke Yes 

13 Tommy Creegan No 

14 Latonya Crisp‐Saura Yes 

15 Richard Davis Yes 

18 Grigory Dunichev Yes 

19 Jolly Eapen Yes 

20 Derrick Echevarria Yes 

22 Pete Foley Yes 

23 Mario Galvet Yes 

24 Angel Giboyeaux Yes 

25 Jerry Greenhaus Yes 

26 Annie Hallahan Yes 

27 Kevin Harrington Yes

  28 Lee Ireland Yes 

29 Maurice Jenkins Yes 

30 Benita Johnson Yes 

31 Tom Lenane Yes 

33 Cleveland Manley Yes 

34 Shirley Martin               Yes 

35 Dennis McCormick Yes

38 Gwendolina Peebles Yes 

40 Paul Piazza Yes

41 Nelson Rivera Yes 

44 John H. Spicer, Jr Yes 

45 Robert H. Stahl Yes 

46 K.Taylor‐Davidson Yes 

48 Tony Utano Yes 

49 Brander White Yes 

50 Christine Williams Yes 

52 Michael Morales Yes 

53 Joe Sclafani Yes

# Keypad Name Response

5 Having found Israel Rivera, Jr guilty on the allegations under charges 1 ‐ 4 brought by John Samuelsen, the board votes to immediately remove him from office of Secretary Treasurer

1 Terry Adams Yes 

2 Tony Aiken Yes 

3 Brussard Alston Yes

4 Lloyd Archer Yes 

5 Frank Austin Yes 

6 Edwin Benjamin Yes 

7 Jack Blazejewicz Yes 

8 Dennis Boyd Yes 

9 Ron Carter Yes

10 John V Chiarello Yes 

11 Eze Chisolm Yes 

12 Brian Clarke Yes 

13 Tommy Creegan No 

14 Latonya Crisp‐Saura Yes 

15 Richard Davis Yes 

18 Grigory Dunichev Yes 

19 Jolly Eapen Yes 

20 Derrick Echevarria Yes 

22 Pete Foley Yes 

23 Mario Galvet Yes 

24 Angel Giboyeaux Yes 

25 Jerry Greenhaus Yes 

26 Annie Hallahan Yes 

27 Kevin Harrington Yes

  28 Lee Ireland Yes 

29 Maurice Jenkins Yes 

30 Benita Johnson Yes 

31 Tom Lenane Yes 

33 Cleveland Manley Yes 

34 Shirley Martin Yes 

35 Dennis McCormick Yes

38 Gwendolina Peebles Yes 

40 Paul Piazza Yes

41 Nelson Rivera Yes 

44 John H. Spicer, Jr Yes 

45 Robert H. Stahl Yes 

46 K.Taylor‐Davidson Yes 

48 Tony Utano Yes 

49 Brander White Yes 

50 Christine Williams Yes 

52 Michael Morales Yes 

53 Joe Sclafani Yes

# Keypad Name Response

6 Israel Rivera, Jr shall be ineligible to hold any office or appointive position in the local or international union for a period of (3) Three Years, the maximum allowable under the constitution of TWU

1 Terry Adams Yes 

2 Tony Aiken Yes 

3 Brussard Alston Yes

4 Lloyd Archer Yes 

5 Frank Austin Yes 

6 Edwin Benjamin Yes 

7 Jack Blazejewicz Yes 

8 Dennis Boyd Yes 

9 Ron Carter Yes

10 John V Chiarello Yes 

11 Eze Chisolm Yes 

12 Brian Clarke Yes 

13 Tommy Creegan No 

14 Latonya Crisp‐Saura Yes 

15 Richard Davis Yes 

18 Grigory Dunichev Yes 

19 Jolly Eapen Yes 

20 Derrick Echevarria Yes 

22 Pete Foley Yes 

23 Mario Galvet Yes 

24 Angel Giboyeaux Yes 

25 Jerry Greenhaus Yes 

26 Annie Hallahan Yes 

27 Kevin Harrington Yes

  28 Lee Ireland Yes 

29 Maurice Jenkins Yes 

30 Benita Johnson Yes 

31 Tom Lenane Yes 

33 Cleveland Manley Yes 

34 Shirley Martin Yes 

35 Dennis McCormick Yes

38 Gwendolina Peebles Yes 

40 Paul Piazza Yes

41 Nelson Rivera Yes 

44 John H. Spicer, Jr Yes 

45 Robert H. Stahl Yes 

46 K.Taylor‐Davidson Yes 

48 Tony Utano Yes 

49 Brander White Yes 

50 Christine Williams Yes 

52 Michael Morales Yes 

53 Joe Sclafani Yes

# Keypad Name Response

7 If allowed by the TWU International Union, Israel Rivera, Jr. shall be barred from holding the position of TWU LOCAL 100 Secretary Treasurer for life

1 Terry Adams No 

2 Tony Aiken No 

3 Brussard Alston Abstain

5 Frank Austin Abstain 

6 Edwin Benjamin Yes 

7 Jack Blazejewicz Abstain 

8 Dennis Boyd No 

10 John V Chiarello Abstain 

11 Eze Chisolm Abstain 

12 Brian Clarke No 

13 Tommy Creegan No  

15 Richard Davis No 

18 Grigory Dunichev No 

19 Jolly Eapen No 

20 Derrick Echevarria No 

22 Pete Foley No 

23 Mario Galvet No 

24 Angel Giboyeaux Abstain 

25 Jerry Greenhaus No 

26 Annie Hallahan Yes 

27 Kevin Harrington Yes

  28 Lee Ireland No 

29 Maurice Jenkins Yes 

30 Benita Johnson Abstain 

31 Tom Lenane Yes 

33 Cleveland Manley Abstain 

34 Shirley Martin Yes 

35 Dennis McCormick Abstain

38 Gwendolina Peebles Yes 

40 Paul Piazza Yes

41 Nelson Rivera No

44 John H. Spicer, Jr Abstain 

45 Robert H. Stahl Abstain 

46 K.Taylor‐Davidson No 

48 Tony Utano Abstain 

49 Brander White Yes 

50 Christine Williams Abstain 

52 Michael Morales No 

53 Joe Sclafani No

Vote Summary

# Question Total Votes Yes No: Abstain

1 Motion to vote Israel Rivera Jr guilty on 43 35 5 3

charge #1 

2 Motion to vote Israel Rivera, Jr. Guilty of the 42 39 1 2

allegations in Charge #2

3 Motion to vote Israel Rivera, Jr. guilty of the 39 37 1 1    

allegations in Charge #3 

4 Motion to vote Israel Rivera, Jr guilty of the 39 37 2

Charge #4

5 Having found Israel Rivera, Jr guilty 39 38 1

on the allegations under charges 1 ‐ 4 

brought by John Samuelsen, 

the board votes to immediately 

remove him from office of Secretary Treasurer

6 Israel Rivera, Jr shall be ineligible to hold any 38 37 1 

office or appointive position in the local or 

international union for a period of (3) 

Three Years, the maximum allowable 

under the constitution of TWU

7 If allowed by the TWU International Union, 39 9 17 13

Israel Rivera, Jr. shall be barred from 

holding the position of TWU LOCAL 100 

Secretary Treasurer for life